I am just getting started, experimenting with dyes. I am trying to figure out the advantages and disadvantages of using water, alcohol, acetone or other solutions for my dyes. I am eager to hear your thoughts and experiences.
I don't have a lot of interest in coloring wood. However, all you guys should take a look at Curtis' colored box in the gallery section above. Now that is some fine work by any standard.I use the Craftsupplies USA Artisan Dyes. They are alcohol based dyes. But I'm not convinced it matters what brand you use. Everyone will have their own favorite. I think hockenberry pretty much nailed it with his reasons why he prefers alcohol based dyes. I've never used water or oil based color though so I can't really say for sure. Color is such a subjective thing that it's impossible to say what looks best. Some woods dye better than others and when you're shooting for a particular color you have to keep in mind that the color of the wood will have a strong influence simply because the dyes are transparent. And unlike many of the techniques used in turning, practice really doesn't seem to help much in coloring. There are too many variables. Every colored piece is an experiment. One thing that coloring wood for a few years has taught me though is that it isn't necessary to have every color available. Black and the primary colors, red, blue, and yellow will give you every color and shade you can imagine.
@Bill Blasic , what do you wear for gloves when handling acetone? I find that it quickly penetrates 5 mil nitrile gloves.
I put my dyes on with transfer pipettes or air brushes so nitrile glove works because when I get to hold the piece where the dye has been administered it is basically dry. I don't think that it has ever penetrated my glove.@Bill Blasic , what do you wear for gloves when handling acetone? I find that it quickly penetrates 5 mil nitrile gloves.
Never tried the alcohol nor the oil-based - never will - I got the results I wanted.
SUGGESTION: Get one type and get good with it.