Howdy Charlie.........
I've never been to an AAW symposium, but I've seen the videos.......
I'd say a goal to be a standout among this crowd is a bit too idealistic because everyone exhibiting there, is showing us their best works. As you say, a more realistic goal might be to blend in among that group who might be considered among the best at the showing. As for "form, finish, largeness, brownness, shiny, etc", unless a turner can come up with something truly unique, that nobody has ever done before.....which also has riveting style and universal appeal, it would be hard to use those things to target a turning with the stated goals in mind.
Then again, our tastes are so diverse, that "universal appeal" is something that will be darn near impossible to achieve.....ie: what appeals to me isn't going to be appreciated in the same way as everyone else sees it......and vise versa.
Now, if you were someone like a David Ellsworth, and were introducing something new, creative, and has that super appeal factor, you might be a standout........but, now everyone and their uncle are producing hollow forms with tiny openings. Even David Ellsworth wouldn't be a standout among the legions of turners who are his own personal "herd" of followers.......that is, if his fame weren't a part of the equation. What makes DE special to us now, is the pedestal he stands on! These hollow turnings are "ho hum" now, but were truly unique and awe inspiring a few decades ago, when DE rose to stardom......
I couldn't ever become the standout in the crowd, because my goals aren't in tune with those who aspire to stardom.....it's not a part of my equation. My personal goal is to achieve mastery over what I do......and, this means doing it not once, but consistently.....over, and over, and over, again. Most assuredly, there are those who are looking for that one thing, that "silver bullet", along with impeccable timing that catapults them to stardom.....and then ride that wave! However, there really isn't anything I do that someone else hasn't done before, so I'll never be a "star" among woodturners.......which brings it back full circle to what my real goals are in the first place!
ooc