• Congratulations to Curt Vogt winner of the February 2025 Turning Challenge (click here for details)
  • Congratulations Mark Durrenberger for "Ripples in Apple" being selected as Turning of the Week for February 24, 2025 (click here for details)
  • Welcome new registering member. Your username must be your real First and Last name (for example: John Doe). "Screen names" and "handles" are not allowed and your registration will be deleted if you don't use your real name. Also, do not use all caps nor all lower case.

February 2025 Challenge: Choose Your Box!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Michael Anderson

Super Moderator
Staff member
TOTW Team
Joined
Aug 22, 2022
Messages
1,802
Likes
5,788
Location
Chattanooga, TN
Hi everyone,

A few days ago, I had decided on a theme for February's challenge. Then, by coincidence, I ran into Mike Hunter at the Tennessee Woodturning Symposium and he suggested a similar idea. Then it clicked--why not both (plus a third option)? What I mean is:

This month's turning challenge is to turn a box. Not just any box--one of the following three. Boxes require a varied skillset, and are, in my opinion, one of the best pieces of functional art out there. There are myriad box designs, but for this challenge I wanted to pick three different design that also had accompanying process videos. Each of these boxes requires different techniques, but all are beautiful and interesting in their own ways. Here they are, in alphabetical order of the turner that developed the design.

BoxNT.jpg
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UNU7FOBBmYw
Neil Turner's urchin box is characterized by an internal stem that also serves as a plunger fit for the lid. It is unique in that there is no lip between the lid and body. Neil embellishes the box post-lathe, but for this challenge that step is optional. Prioritize the form, not the carving.


BoxRK.jpg
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TwNNsFEUsCw
Ray Key's final box is characterized by a seamless transition between the body and the lid with an integrated finial. The finial lid fits into the recess of body like a plug, and the flowing curves from small base to tip produce a quite beautiful and dreamy form.


BoxRR.jpeg
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xzYPNe8pTU4
Richard Raffan's crossgrain box is characterized by a loose-fitting and overhanging lid with integrated knob, a tapered body, and distinct transitions between design features. The loose lid facilitates being able to turn a box from crossgrain material (as opposed to end grain). Note: blanks must be dry.


I hope this is a fun challenge that appeals to a broad group of folks. Boxes are special, so do your best work. Here are the rules, as determined by AAW Forum legal counsel Dewey, Cheatum, and Howe:
  • Entries must shadow one of these three forms. Feel free to add your own flair, but be sure you stick to the roadmap.
  • Boxes may be embellished as desired, or left natural.
  • Entries must include two photographs: one of the box closed, and one of the box open (lid still included in shot).
  • Entries must be posted in this thread by ~11:59 pm Coordinated Universal Time (UTC) on February 24, 2025.
  • As always, this is a turning contest, not a "moldy oldie" photo contest, so in fairness to everybody, make sure your work is something you have made since this challenge was issued on February 2, 2025.
  • You may not post any photos of your entry in this month’s challenge in any other thread or in the gallery until the voting has ended and a winner has been declared.
  • Voting will take place from February 25, 2025, through 11:59 pm UTC on February 28, 2025.
  • Solicitation of votes will result in disqualification.
  • The winner might have to pass a lie detector test before collecting the grand prize of a dogleg high-carbon continental gouge. Good luck, have fun, make shavings, and let the chips fall where they may!!
 
Last edited:
Ok question. Specifically for the finial box, but can apply to the others I guess. Does the design have to be a similar interface as the example box? I'm thinking that the finial is integrated to an infitting lid or can it be any endgrain box with a finial of some sort. Thanks in advance for clarification.

Gregory
 
Ok question. Specifically for the finial box, but can apply to the others I guess. Does the design have to be a similar interface as the example box? I'm thinking that the finial is integrated to an infitting lid or can it be any endgrain box with a finial of some sort. Thanks in advance for clarification.

Gregory
Hi Gregory,

Thanks for asking. The box (finial box included) needs to be of the same design as in the photo (and the process videos). There can be specific design additions, but it needs to follow the form above. The idea with this is to present three separate options, each with a reference photo and an associated how-to video.
 
Hi Gregory,

Thanks for asking. The box (finial box included) needs to be of the same design as in the photo (and the process videos). There can be specific design additions, but it needs to follow the form above. The idea with this is present three separate options, each with a reference photo and an associated how-to video.
Thanks just wanted to make sure I understood correctly.

Gregory
 
Minor interjection here. We’re sort of straying from the original purpose/rules of the challenge: create a box that closely follows one of the three forms I laid out. Unique versions are allowed, of course, but at the very least the characteristic features I listed in the descriptions need to be included in the final design. Additionally, the box needs to have been created this month. As much as I hate to do so, for the sake of the spirit of the challenge I am deleting the entries that don’t follow the rules. Apologies if your entry gets deleted—that decision has nothing to do with the quality of your box. Every example posted here is very nice, seriously.
 
This month the AAW Turning Challenge happened to hit at the same time I had decided to try and progress in my box making skills. Without the challenge, I doubt I would have made any of the three box styles of the challenge, but each one gave me new opportunities to improve at the lathe. I made all three, but at the risk of getting on the bad side of the legal powerhouse of Dewey, Cheatum, and Howe, I had to choose my one favorite of the three boxes to post here. Here is the Raffan style box in Curly Maple. 3” tall by 3.5” wide with wipe on poly finish.CV AAW Raffan Style 1.jpgCV AAW Challenge Raffan Style  2.jpg
 
I was hoping to have another shot at this but I'm running out of time and my subsequent attempts have issues of their own - so the one I completed will have to do. The wood is amur cork bark tree. I'd point out all the things I am unhappy with but you will figure those out on your own 😄,

PSP_P2120049.jpg
PSP_P2120003.jpgPSP_P2120050.jpg
 

Attachments

  • PSP_P2120051.jpg
    PSP_P2120051.jpg
    575.6 KB · Views: 6
Here is my attempt at the Ray Key finial box. I made it from a piece of figured walnut that was on the edge of a piece of walnut burl; because of the inconsistent grain, the lid does not match the grain of the base perfectly. The lid is also a spinning top, and it'll spin around 40 seconds pretty consistently (I included an action shot of it spinning).
 

Attachments

  • Feb_Box_Walnut.jpg
    Feb_Box_Walnut.jpg
    130 KB · Views: 32
Here's my version of Ray's Box out of Hackberry. This is a deceptively simple design.
Even though Ray's technique differed from mine I tried to use his methods as much as possible. This meant using the skew much more than I'm comfortable with, but I'm growing to like it.
Oh, and the lid comes off with a resounding POP!

Box 2.jpgBox.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top