At least the man was caught and charged.
All old trees should be protected, in my never humble opinion..
A small, swampy wooded lot was cleared in my area about a year ago. It was on a main thoroughfare, bordered on three sides by stores/plazas (how it survived as long as it did, I don't know).
I thought it was mostly small trees, 6-8" around, but when I asked the guys if I could poke around their tree piles they took me to one of the biggest maples I've seen in Florida.
Where I started cutting it was 38" across, and where I stopped cutting on it (12' later) was 48" across. I didn't really have storage room for 12' of tree that size (or 3 days to spend cutting and transporting the chunks), but I would be damned before I let that tree rot at the dump or get mulched.
A tree like that should never be allowed to be cut down. It's probably been here longer than we have, so build around it.
...and what's worse, a year later and no construction has taken place - they just turned a wooded lot into a swampy weed bed.
There's a slot limit on fish, why not trees?