• It's time to cast your vote in the January 2025 Turning Challenge. (click here for details)
  • Conversations are now Direct Messages (click here for details)
  • Congratulations to Alan Weinberg for "Elm Burl Bowl" being selected as Turning of the Week for January 27, 2025 (click here for details)
  • Welcome new registering member. Your username must be your real First and Last name (for example: John Doe). "Screen names" and "handles" are not allowed and your registration will be deleted if you don't use your real name. Also, do not use all caps nor all lower case.

AAW symposium

Joined
Jun 13, 2018
Messages
44
Likes
300
Location
Harrington, Delaware
this was my first time at the “big” AAW event. I did go to the segmented symposium in StLouis in 2018. it was a much more specific show I am more of a segmented guy any way but not limited to that.

My experience was great I had an amazing time and talked to a lot of people. All the demos that I attended were amazing. I can only speak for what I saw. The people were kind as well. I have been to a lot of trade shows over the years, BIG YRADE SHOWS.. there are always those guys walking around with the I’m better than every one attitude I have even see some pretty good fights at trade shows. This was nothing like that at all I really enjoyed every thing.

Having said all of that I would like to put a few things out there that I heard over and over again. I talked to over 100 people while I was there And I heard many things over and over again.

1- The show is not what it use to be. It would bring in more money and so on. I can’t attest to that this is my first one so I have Nothing to gauge it by. Some said it changed when the economy crashed and never fully recovered some said it was because the members were getting older and there were not as many collectors because some had passed away. I took the class in grants through the AAW. They pretty much echoed this by saying in recent years they have seen a serious decline in people seeking grants..

A. Why does the AAW not hold an open panel discussion that brain storms new ideas to possibly help grow the AAW. What are clubs doing to grow memberships and so on

B. Why not give one of the raffle lathes to an AAW member that is serious about wood turning and is a 5 year or less member. Create an incentive for new members.

C. Cultivate the SoCal media presence of the AAW. Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, a weekly short instructional video in the YouTube channel these can be submitted by clubs or individuals and attention can be diverted to the persons group or page that supplied the video. A weekly meet the turner. Shop tours and other related videos.

D. A pod cast. I watch a lot of pod casts don’t just bring in wood turners. Talk to all kinds of artists. Social media experts. Video and photography experts bring gallery owners on and talk to them. Pro wood turners, beginners, people changing the industry with new tools, methods, or materials. Talk to business owners even if they are not in the Woodturning world about how to grow a business. A good pod cast with a good verity of guests will make some money and draw a crowd. Imagine getting Mike Roe on there just to talk about work ethic. That could be an amazing opportunity for the AAW. All kinds of wood workers and artists the possibility’s are endless



2- this has little to do with the AAW or symposium but I was told by many that there are not a lot of places for wood turners to show there work seriously the number of serious gallery’s that deal in wood art can be counted on 1 hand.

A. Would it be possible for the AAW to do there own on line gallery like wood symphony. There is no actual gallery. Hire some one to curate it pay them with commission. Allow all wood artists to be able to show there work in various gallery’s and category’s with a commission going to the AAW.. again just a thought

3- i was told by probably 4 people that my prices were a bit high on the prices that I took with me and I would not be able to sell them at that price. I was also told by several people that if I didn’t change certain aspects of my work serious collectors probably would not be interested in purchasing my work. I also heard from no less than 10 people that people just didn’t understand what they were looking at and could not wrap there head around what they were seeing while looking at my work. I was also told by several people I should expect for my work to not be recognized for about 10 years.

A. I sell a high % of my pieces. And they ship around the world. My sphere series all sold long before any of them were ever finished for the asking price. I have never had a problem getting asking price. Some pieces I will admit I price high because I have an attachment to them. In those cases I don’t care if they sell or not if they do it’s cool. Am I being told this in an attempt to get me to lower my price to what they want to pay? Or are my prices really to high

B. Changing my work to fit collectors. Should I do that? I didn’t start doing this to appease people I did this for me. Of corse I would like to sell my work. Every thing I make is fore sale. On commissioned pieces I ask what’s your budget and I stay inside of it but over all even with that I will take a basic shape or object that the buyer is interested in and I do what I want with it. I tell people up front that I need a lot of freedom on my pieces. I am selling a lot of my work to people OUTSIDE of the Woodturning community. Doesn’t catering to a small group of people inside the community decrease the amount of NEW people I’m reaching. I don’t want to be limited to people just inside the community. I want to reach them all. I want my pieces to be right at home in the biggest art gallery’s that have never sold a single wood piece. I want it to help bring new people in and not just make happy what’s already here.

C. Should I tone down my work if woodworkers don’t understand will others? Does it matter ? Should it just be visually stunning? So no matter who you are your drawn to it because a lot of the work I have shown so far is just practice. I’m experimenting and planning. Developing new ideas and Techniques. I have things in the works that are going to confuse a lot of people but it’s going to take some time before I’m ready to show it.

D. The work won’t be recognized for about 10 years that kinda bothered me a bit. If that’s the case I should just drop my AAW membership and stick to what I’m doing because I’m doing pretty well on my own my social media accounts are growing pretty quick and the majority of people I interact with are normal people outside of the wood turning community. I’m not just going to Twittle my thumbs for 10 years I’m going to make my own way. So there is a question here are people in the AAW group hurting them selves with some of these ways of thinking. Should the goal not be to cultivate the industry instead of saying your going to have to take a back seat for 10 years. How many AMAZING turners have just walked away from groups like this just for that reason.

Every thing I written about is intended to be positive I’m already planning on going to next years event. I really enjoy this stuff I just wish I had more time to invest into it.
 
Ed seems a little bit of a rambling post. I will address one thing . At most symposiums , including regional , there is a meeting with the board and usually invited are club officers. This meeting allows idea presentation and the board addresses concerns while outlining upcoming plans for AAW. I have found it very open and of the few I have been to there were Ideas presented that the board did pursue.

So the basic idea is if you think change is needed : Get Involved in Leadership!
 
looked @ ur gallery
Pretty good form
Segmented ...not my strong suit
If ur are selling just let it roll off....lots of opinions out there
Finish .... Crows would like it
 
@ed polite - you offered lots of interesting things to contemplate.

I can address a few

1. You may have missed the members meeting. Or did not catch the brief mention of future plans AAW has for adding other media to the printed journal. These plans all came from focus groups run by chapters and surveys of local chapters

2. Not sure who told you it takes 10 years to get recognized. Some never get recognized others get noticed in 2 -3 years. You are in the window. 10 years was probably thrown out so you don’t get discouraged.

Collectors of wood art all have their biases - one commonly held is not wanting derivative work. So anyone with new high quality work not seen before tends to be a wanted addition for collectors.

3. There are lots of ways to get noticed at a AAW. a couple are:
Getting work accepted for the juried shows, Pop Auction, Benefit Auction
Apply for the Pop “featured artist”
Apply to demonstrate
Submit an outline and a few photos for articles for the journal or fundamental and
write the article if accepted.

All these above are quite competitive. Many more qualified applicants and worthy pieces are submitted than can be accepted. Part of getting accepted is having a write up or piece that connects with one or more of selection Comittee or jury members. The jury’s and selection comittee change every year so what doesn’t connect one year might well connect the next.
 
There was a period about 13-15 years ago when there were some fantastic pieces being created that went to collectors who did not seem to care how much money they were spending 25-30,000 dollars for some of Vesery and Kleins tops.
The recession ( and other factors ) put an end to that sort of spending.
When the demand slacked off, some of the artists stopped making those type of (master)pieces.
That was a long time ago. There has been a 'reset' of sorts.

I have found that board members are receptive to ideas. As noted there were two open sessions for members at the symposium.

The EOG ( Educational Opportunity Grant ) fund is a way for members and clubs to get equipment, take classes, or provide classes.
It is open to all members. It is funded by the Auction.
POP also offers assistance .

10 years is a long time, it may be that some folks took that long to be noticed.
It may be that it takes a few years to 'find your voice' and produce work that stands out from the crowd.
A turner with a new way of looking at the craft and producing high quality work will be noticed right away in the Instant Gallery.
At the banquet awards were announced for new and exceptional work in the IG.
I missed the IG critique, one of my favorite sessions. Where often new names are chosen for their moment in the sun.
It wasn't crazy stuff, just well done and individual.

Everyone sees something different when they look at a piece.
It is a fairly rare piece that resonates with a bunch of people.
You find that combination and suddenly everyone knows ( or wants to know ) your name.
 
My opinion on galleries is that they took 3 strikes, The 2008 crash, aging patrons and collectors, and social media. Many did not keep up with social media, artists did.
Why are you so concerned about other turner's opinions, shortage of galleries and pricing when you can sell out before you complete the work?
 
G
this was my first time at the “big” AAW event. I did go to the segmented symposium in StLouis in 2018. it was a much more specific show I am more of a segmented guy any way but not limited to that.

My experience was great I had an amazing time and talked to a lot of people. All the demos that I attended were amazing. I can only speak for what I saw. The people were kind as well. I have been to a lot of trade shows over the years, BIG YRADE SHOWS.. there are always those guys walking around with the I’m better than every one attitude I have even see some pretty good fights at trade shows. This was nothing like that at all I really enjoyed every thing.

Having said all of that I would like to put a few things out there that I heard over and over again. I talked to over 100 people while I was there And I heard many things over and over again.

1- The show is not what it use to be. It would bring in more money and so on. I can’t attest to that this is my first one so I have Nothing to gauge it by. Some said it changed when the economy crashed and never fully recovered some said it was because the members were getting older and there were not as many collectors because some had passed away. I took the class in grants through the AAW. They pretty much echoed this by saying in recent years they have seen a serious decline in people seeking grants..

A. Why does the AAW not hold an open panel discussion that brain storms new ideas to possibly help grow the AAW. What are clubs doing to grow memberships and so on

B. Why not give one of the raffle lathes to an AAW member that is serious about wood turning and is a 5 year or less member. Create an incentive for new members.

C. Cultivate the SoCal media presence of the AAW. Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, a weekly short instructional video in the YouTube channel these can be submitted by clubs or individuals and attention can be diverted to the persons group or page that supplied the video. A weekly meet the turner. Shop tours and other related videos.

D. A pod cast. I watch a lot of pod casts don’t just bring in wood turners. Talk to all kinds of artists. Social media experts. Video and photography experts bring gallery owners on and talk to them. Pro wood turners, beginners, people changing the industry with new tools, methods, or materials. Talk to business owners even if they are not in the Woodturning world about how to grow a business. A good pod cast with a good verity of guests will make some money and draw a crowd. Imagine getting Mike Roe on there just to talk about work ethic. That could be an amazing opportunity for the AAW. All kinds of wood workers and artists the possibility’s are endless



2- this has little to do with the AAW or symposium but I was told by many that there are not a lot of places for wood turners to show there work seriously the number of serious gallery’s that deal in wood art can be counted on 1 hand.

A. Would it be possible for the AAW to do there own on line gallery like wood symphony. There is no actual gallery. Hire some one to curate it pay them with commission. Allow all wood artists to be able to show there work in various gallery’s and category’s with a commission going to the AAW.. again just a thought

3- i was told by probably 4 people that my prices were a bit high on the prices that I took with me and I would not be able to sell them at that price. I was also told by several people that if I didn’t change certain aspects of my work serious collectors probably would not be interested in purchasing my work. I also heard from no less than 10 people that people just didn’t understand what they were looking at and could not wrap there head around what they were seeing while looking at my work. I was also told by several people I should expect for my work to not be recognized for about 10 years.

A. I sell a high % of my pieces. And they ship around the world. My sphere series all sold long before any of them were ever finished for the asking price. I have never had a problem getting asking price. Some pieces I will admit I price high because I have an attachment to them. In those cases I don’t care if they sell or not if they do it’s cool. Am I being told this in an attempt to get me to lower my price to what they want to pay? Or are my prices really to high

B. Changing my work to fit collectors. Should I do that? I didn’t start doing this to appease people I did this for me. Of corse I would like to sell my work. Every thing I make is fore sale. On commissioned pieces I ask what’s your budget and I stay inside of it but over all even with that I will take a basic shape or object that the buyer is interested in and I do what I want with it. I tell people up front that I need a lot of freedom on my pieces. I am selling a lot of my work to people OUTSIDE of the Woodturning community. Doesn’t catering to a small group of people inside the community decrease the amount of NEW people I’m reaching. I don’t want to be limited to people just inside the community. I want to reach them all. I want my pieces to be right at home in the biggest art gallery’s that have never sold a single wood piece. I want it to help bring new people in and not just make happy what’s already here.

C. Should I tone down my work if woodworkers don’t understand will others? Does it matter ? Should it just be visually stunning? So no matter who you are your drawn to it because a lot of the work I have shown so far is just practice. I’m experimenting and planning. Developing new ideas and Techniques. I have things in the works that are going to confuse a lot of people but it’s going to take some time before I’m ready to show it.

D. The work won’t be recognized for about 10 years that kinda bothered me a bit. If that’s the case I should just drop my AAW membership and stick to what I’m doing because I’m doing pretty well on my own my social media accounts are growing pretty quick and the majority of people I interact with are normal people outside of the wood turning community. I’m not just going to Twittle my thumbs for 10 years I’m going to make my own way. So there is a question here are people in the AAW group hurting them selves with some of these ways of thinking. Should the goal not be to cultivate the industry instead of saying your going to have to take a back seat for 10 years. How many AMAZING turners have just walked away from groups like this just for that reason.

Every thing I written about is intended to be positive I’m already planning on going to next years event. I really enjoy this stuff I just wish I had more time to invest into it.
Dittos what Gerald said, with so many ideas, get involved, run for the AAW board.
 
Back
Top